Miss Norledge's Storeroom
  • Home
  • Resources by Topic
    • Number and Proportion
    • Algebra
    • Shape
  • Blog
    • Summer Blog Challenge
    • Staffrm 29 Days of Writing (2016)
    • Maths with Zoombinis
  • My resources
    • Downloads >
      • Mix Match
      • Rally Coach
      • Pass the Problem
    • Request a password
  • Links
    • Teaching blogs and resources
    • Web tools and apps
    • Exams and assessment
  • Privacy Policy
  • Home
  • Resources by Topic
    • Number and Proportion
    • Algebra
    • Shape
  • Blog
    • Summer Blog Challenge
    • Staffrm 29 Days of Writing (2016)
    • Maths with Zoombinis
  • My resources
    • Downloads >
      • Mix Match
      • Rally Coach
      • Pass the Problem
    • Request a password
  • Links
    • Teaching blogs and resources
    • Web tools and apps
    • Exams and assessment
  • Privacy Policy

             

  

Teaching solving equations

17/3/2015

 
The teaching methods I use for solving equations have changed drastically over my (relatively short) career so far, so here's a post about my journey so far and current "tried and tested" ideas.
1. Why animal algebra doesn't work
One very clear memory I have of my time at school is the first term of work I did in Year 7. My teacher was properly "old-school" - he'd demonstrate for 15 minutes, then we'd work in silence for the remaining 45 minutes on similar problems. He was the deputy head, and we were all pretty terrified of him; while I don't want to debate if that's a good teaching model or not, one thing that really stuck with me was that first term's work - we did nothing but solving equations, pretty much from September until Christmas. It wasn't just simple linear though; we went all the way to solving quadratics using the formula, although I confess I didn't really know what I was doing or why I was doing it. As a result, I've always loved algebra and been pretty good at it (conversely, my geometrical reasoning skills are pretty dire). 
He taught us equations by drawing see-saws with cats, dogs, elephants and frogs perched on one side, and numbers on the other. Gradually the animals disappeared to be replaced by letters, until we were solving some pretty complicated equations, including unknowns both sides, negative and fractional answers and coefficients.

Because it stuck with me so much, I tried it when I started teaching. Didn't work in the slightest; here's a prime example of having to find your own ways of explaining things - what worked for a group of top set kids in a pretty high-attaining middle school in Staffordshire just didn't seem to translate to my teaching with kids who had never understood algebra in the slightest and were just bemused by the pictures of animals appearing everywhere. I realised that, although this method had clicked with me, it was clouding the issue for many of my pupils, and I stopped trying to teach animal algebra soon after that.
2. Clarity of notation
During the second week of my NQT year, we had a department Ofsted - as I discovered later, the lady who observed me was Jane Jones, their mathematics leader, and our school was one of those used to compile their "Mathematics: Made to Measure" report published in 2012. As I was absolutely petrified at the thought of big ol' scary Ofsted turning up when I'd not even got settled in, I was pleased that my lesson went OK. However, in my feedback, Jane mentioned one thing that I'd not even thought about before - the way that my presentation was confusing some of the pupils:
Picture
Dividing both sides of the equation by 2
Picture
The correct solution...
Picture
And what some pupils were doing instead!
At this stage, I was in the habit of writing the inverse operation below the equation before doing the next line of working. 

Although this worked fine for most pupils, some were getting confused about exactly what the "divide by 2" referred to, and were simply dividing the x coefficient by 2, rather than the whole of the left-hand side of the equation.

Some were also mixing up their working with the equation, ending up with lines of working and solution blending into each other and creating even more confusion.
During my second year of teaching, I discovered an A Level pupil solving equations like this:
Picture
She consistently used this presentation in her working; she explained that she wrote down how she was transforming both sides of the equation on the right-hand side of the line, with her solution on the left-hand side.

I went away and trialled this with my Year 10s; they loved it as a method for organising their working, so I now present all my algebraic working like this.
One major benefit of this is how well it translates to other branches of algebra; I get pupils to include "expand", "factorise" or "square root" in their right-hand columns when creating examples for revision to remind them exactly what they did to get the solution. It also links in really well to work on inverse functions, as it creates a flow-chart of operations which can easily be followed backwards.
3. Conceptual understanding and modelling
Once I'd got my notation sorted, I started thinking more critically about the conceptual issues pupils were having with solving equations. My teaching at this point was still mostly procedural; do one example, then get the pupils to practise loads more. I think there's still an argument for doing this, as fluidity in solving equations is so important for higher-level topics, but I think I was teaching the process and hoping that understanding would miraculously appear later (it didn't).

Following on from my experience on the NCETM course last year, I started to try and incorporate more ideas about modelling situations into work across the board. I also took a different approach to the whole topic; before even going near solving equations, I got pupils to build their own. I used Fred and George (yes, the Harry Potter twins - they pop up a lot in my random examples), who have to have equal money spent on them for presents, and got pupils to model this, using p as the cost of a present.
Picture
Picture
Picture
We spent a couple of lessons creating our own equations before even thinking about solving them, and I started to encourage the line notation for pupils to show their working out.

This seemed to work quite well as a conceptual model for them, and was infinitely preferable to using animal algebra, as a present can cost an amount of money, whereas having "a cat is worth 5" is a little meaningless.
By the time we'd finished making up equations, I'd found and started using algebra tiles with my Year 11s to complete the square. I decided to give this a go for linear equations as a way to move from the concrete idea of "a present" towards the more abstract "value of x". 
This worked brilliantly with the groups I trialed it with last year (from high-attaining Year 7s to low-attaining Year 9s), although it's really important to encourage pupils to show their working algebraically as well - you can see how I do this in the video. You can download my algebra tiles lesson here.
4. Multiple solution methods
Something that was embedding misconceptions rather than illuminating them was my presentation of examples and problems to pupils. Making up an equation on the spot, I'm more likely to come up with ax + b = c than b + ax = c or even c = b + ax. Now, I'm consciously trying to include examples of equations written every way round and getting pupils to think carefully about what effect (if any) this has.
Picture
All of these equations are the same, but pupils usually see type 1 in textbooks and on worksheets.
In addition to this, I'm also spending more time looking at alternative solutions, something else which has cropped up more frequently in lessons when pupils are using the algebra tiles rather than following my procedure. I had a lovely discussion with Year 7 last year about the similarities and differences in these two solutions, getting them to think critically about why we subtract 6 in the first example, but 3 in the second.
Picture
Two different ways of dealing with brackets.
5. Looking for links
Where possible, I think it's important that pupils are presented with relevant reasons to solve equations. It's a great opportunity to link in prior knowledge, such as angles on a line or in a triangle, and get them to construct their own equations pretty much straight away.

I also now teach solving inequalities right after (or sometimes simultaneously to) solving equations. I was initially mystified that pupils who could solve complicated equations well somehow got in a complete muddle with inequalities, and I think some of that is our fault; it's frequently presented as a completely disparate topic, not touched until Year 10 or 11, rather than essentially the same process with a different symbol in the middle.

Related posts

Why algebra tiles are the most amazing thing, like, ever
Solving linear equations using algebra tiles

Paul Richards
24/10/2015 00:51:21

Thank you, great blog, from basic teaching to notation. Can't wait to try out the algebra tiles.


Comments are closed.

    Categories

    All
    #29daysofwriting
    A Level
    Algebra
    Algebra Tiles
    Area
    Assessment
    Bar Model
    Bar Modelling
    Books
    Celebration Of Maths 2015
    Challenge
    Circles
    CPD
    Cuisenaire Rods
    Data
    Decimals
    Displays
    Enrichment
    Equations
    Events
    Feedback
    Formulae
    Four Operations
    Fractions
    Functional Maths
    Gcse 2015
    GCSE Past Papers
    GCSE Revision
    Graphs
    Group Work
    HCF And LCM
    History Of Maths
    Intervention
    Investigation
    Lesson
    Lesson Ideas
    Literacy
    Lotw
    Loving Maths
    Manipulatives
    Marking
    Mastery
    #mathsconf
    #mathsconf2015
    #mathsconf4
    Maths In Pictures
    Multiplication
    Musings
    Negative Numbers
    News
    Numeracy Across Curriculum
    Parenthood
    Percentages
    Pick Of Twitter
    Pie Charts
    Primes
    Probability
    Problem Solving
    Proportion Problems
    Puzzles
    Pythagoras
    Quadratics
    Quadratic Sequences
    Ratio Tables
    Real Life Graphs
    Reflection
    Resources
    Revision
    Rounding
    Schemes Of Work
    Simultaneous Equations
    Square Numbers
    Stationery
    #summerblogchallenge
    #teacher5adaysketch
    Teaching And Learning
    Technology
    Top Ten
    Trignometry
    Trigonometry
    Vectors
    Venn Diagrams
    Websites
    Weebly Tutorials
    Zoombinis


    Archives

    August 2020
    September 2018
    August 2018
    October 2017
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    February 2016
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.