Miss Norledge's Storeroom
  • Home
  • Resources by Topic
    • Number and Proportion
    • Algebra
    • Shape
  • Blog
    • Summer Blog Challenge
    • Staffrm 29 Days of Writing (2016)
    • Maths with Zoombinis
  • My resources
    • Downloads >
      • Mix Match
      • Rally Coach
      • Pass the Problem
    • Request a password
  • Links
    • Teaching blogs and resources
    • Web tools and apps
    • Exams and assessment
  • Privacy Policy
  • Home
  • Resources by Topic
    • Number and Proportion
    • Algebra
    • Shape
  • Blog
    • Summer Blog Challenge
    • Staffrm 29 Days of Writing (2016)
    • Maths with Zoombinis
  • My resources
    • Downloads >
      • Mix Match
      • Rally Coach
      • Pass the Problem
    • Request a password
  • Links
    • Teaching blogs and resources
    • Web tools and apps
    • Exams and assessment
  • Privacy Policy

             

  

Multiplication madness? Part 1

2/3/2015

 
As a department, we seem to have spent the last six months debating exactly which method is OK for multiplying large numbers. Personally, I learnt column/long multiplication at school, and got pretty good at it, although to be honest, past about midway through Year 11 I can't recall a situation where I've really had to accurately multiply two large numbers without a calculator - but that's another debate. Teacher training introduced me to the grid method, and I immediately went "ooh fantastic!" and taught that for three years without any critical thought as to whether or not that's even the best method.

Then I did this activity from the NCETM and several of my Year 7s decided they really liked Gelosia multiplication. Some of them had previously been really unsuccessful with grid method - although they understood what they were doing, they invariably lost the odd zero along the way, or made a pig's ear of lining up the addition calculation at the end. I told them to go with Gelosia if they understood it.
Weirdly enough, I started seeing Gelosia popping up on my whiteboard that year from a colleague who had always taught multiplication that way (as Napier's Rods). Then I got a pupil who asked if he could use "the Chinese method" - lo and behold, it was the same thing. Again, I told him to go ahead if he was getting the right answer. It's also known as "lattice" multiplication.

Then all the hoo-ha kicked off about the new Maths curriculum and teaching methods. On one course I attended, we had a fifteen-minute debate about the pros and cons of each method, with vast divisions of opinion. We spent an awfully long time debating the appendix of the new Primary Curriculum - that's this bit:
Picture
- and whether or not "some examples of formal written methods" implied that other methods would be acceptable or not. Couple this with Elizabeth Truss's response about Key Stage 2 testing: 
and I was thoroughly confused about the status of that appendix.

The Key Stage 2 SAMs seem to make things a little clearer - I found this:
"Key stage 2 tests will be designed to reward pupils whose working shows they have used the efficient methods. If children get the right answer, they get the marks. If they get the wrong answer but their working shows that they were using the most efficient methods, they will still be rewarded."
Picture
This seems to imply that the only "formal written method" they are accepting for any method marks is long multiplication. Of course, if this brand spanking new curriculum works as planned and all our Year 7s suddenly start being able to use long multiplication the minute they arrive at secondary school, it's all a moot point, but I think we can assume that, as now, at least some of them will muddle their way through primary without having a clue how to work out 2376 x 15.

So my next question was - is it OK for pupils at GCSE to use any method, or do they have to do long multiplication too to get the method marks? So I went back to the SAMs for a peruse. Edexcel's Foundation Paper 1 has the calculation 24 x 225 (Q3a), with the following in the mark scheme:
M1 for a complete correct method for multiplication with no more than one multiplication error
AQA's Foundation Paper 1 has all three methods (long, lattice and grid) for the calculation 27 x 86 (Q15b) listed in the mark scheme, with method marks specifically given for each stage. I couldn't find a comparable calculation on the OCR papers.

Leaving out the accreditation mess and presuming the exams stay fairly similar, it seems that, although KS2 tests are asking for long multiplication, our GCSE pupils are fine to continue to use whichever method they prefer. 
See Part 2 for a discussion of pros and cons of grid, lattice and long multiplication methods.



Comments are closed.

    Categories

    All
    #29daysofwriting
    A Level
    Algebra
    Algebra Tiles
    Area
    Assessment
    Bar Model
    Bar Modelling
    Books
    Celebration Of Maths 2015
    Challenge
    Circles
    CPD
    Cuisenaire Rods
    Data
    Decimals
    Displays
    Enrichment
    Equations
    Events
    Feedback
    Formulae
    Four Operations
    Fractions
    Functional Maths
    Gcse 2015
    GCSE Past Papers
    GCSE Revision
    Graphs
    Group Work
    HCF And LCM
    History Of Maths
    Intervention
    Investigation
    Lesson
    Lesson Ideas
    Literacy
    Lotw
    Loving Maths
    Manipulatives
    Marking
    Mastery
    #mathsconf
    #mathsconf2015
    #mathsconf4
    Maths In Pictures
    Multiplication
    Musings
    Negative Numbers
    News
    Numeracy Across Curriculum
    Parenthood
    Percentages
    Pick Of Twitter
    Pie Charts
    Primes
    Probability
    Problem Solving
    Proportion Problems
    Puzzles
    Pythagoras
    Quadratics
    Quadratic Sequences
    Ratio Tables
    Real Life Graphs
    Reflection
    Resources
    Revision
    Rounding
    Schemes Of Work
    Simultaneous Equations
    Square Numbers
    Stationery
    #summerblogchallenge
    #teacher5adaysketch
    Teaching And Learning
    Technology
    Top Ten
    Trignometry
    Trigonometry
    Vectors
    Venn Diagrams
    Websites
    Weebly Tutorials
    Zoombinis


    Archives

    August 2020
    September 2018
    August 2018
    October 2017
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    February 2016
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.