Miss Norledge's Storeroom
  • Home
  • Resources by Topic
    • Number and Proportion
    • Algebra
    • Shape
  • Blog
    • Summer Blog Challenge
    • Staffrm 29 Days of Writing (2016)
    • Maths with Zoombinis
  • My resources
    • Downloads >
      • Mix Match
      • Rally Coach
      • Pass the Problem
    • Request a password
  • Links
    • Teaching blogs and resources
    • Web tools and apps
    • Exams and assessment
  • Privacy Policy
  • Home
  • Resources by Topic
    • Number and Proportion
    • Algebra
    • Shape
  • Blog
    • Summer Blog Challenge
    • Staffrm 29 Days of Writing (2016)
    • Maths with Zoombinis
  • My resources
    • Downloads >
      • Mix Match
      • Rally Coach
      • Pass the Problem
    • Request a password
  • Links
    • Teaching blogs and resources
    • Web tools and apps
    • Exams and assessment
  • Privacy Policy

             

  

Bar Modelling - Reflections on Celebration of Maths 2015

11/2/2015

 
Picture
I've been using bar modelling quite extensively in my teaching since being involved with the NCETM's multiplicative reasoning project last year. Part of the project was to emphasise the importance of diagrammatic representations of problems in teaching maths for understanding; we were given materials to deliver to Key Stage 3 classes, some of which included use of Singapore bar modelling for topics such as fractions, percentages and ratio. I found the work we did really altered my teaching; I think that I managed to teach addition of fractions successfully for the first time since I started teaching, and I was amazed at just how well my students retained efficiency and accuracy with "traditional" written methods.

It seemed like a bit of a no-brainer to pick the bar modelling workshop at the Celebration of Maths, so I and my colleagues trotted along to the session, sat down with our mini-whiteboards and got ready to draw some bars. One thing I was really keen to get out of this session was to iron out some issues I still had with using the bar to solve problems with negative amounts, and I was still struggling to see how to apply bar modelling to exam technique (see my attempt with the Edexcel SAMs here).

First of all we looked at some simple problems, like fractions of amounts. I'm already pretty happy with this - there are plenty of examples of stuff like this in my Year 7's books at the moment. I was so proud of myself that I thought I'd add a really constructive "what went well" to my work too.
Picture
Using a bar model to find 3/5 of 30.
However, something I'd not thought of consciously is the importance of getting students to also write down the calculations they are doing. You can see in the picture I've written down that I did 30 รท 5 to get 6 for 1/5 of the whole amount, but I rarely get students to do this at the moment. I've noticed that some students naturally move away from drawing a bar once they have done a few problems and can "see" what's going on, but I'm going to enforce writing of calculations too from now on, in the hope that more of them will be able to make this step.

Something else that I realised was that I'd been thinking about bar modelling all wrong; it's a tool for developing understanding, not just "another method", and I'm aware that, in some cases, I've been treating bar modelling as a method (again, see my struggle with the SAMs). This session really clarified in my mind that the bar isn't a replacement for traditional methods in terms of efficiency, and I really shouldn't hold back students who already understand by insisting they use bars all the time; it's more of a stepping stone to get them to understand and think critically about the calculations they are doing, so they can move from concrete/pictoral representations to being able to solve the problems using "just numbers".

Next up, we looked at equations. I developed and trialled a load of algebra tiles resources of the back of the NCETM project last year, which have been quite successful. I've not taught solving equations from scratch yet this year, but I'm planning on marrying up the work with algebra tiles and bar modelling. Rather than actually do the problems in the presentation, we decided to have a heated discussion about how to deal with negatives in equations instead (yes, like those annoying kids who don't pay attention to what's actually going on!).

Here are our thoughts and diagrams for 2a - 1 = 5. We really struggled to get our heads around how to represent a negative amount or subtraction on the bar!
Picture
Picture
Picture
We finally cracked it (kinda) with the second and third diagrams. If you think about the equation as "the difference between 2a and 5 is 1", then you can show this using blocks. I'm still not sure whether or not I actually want to put a negative sign with that 5. You can then see that 2a = 6 and deduce that a = 3.

This took quite a while, and caused a lot of hurty heads! We concluded that bar modelling was really useful when introducing solving equations, if done with positive numbers and solutions, but that working with negative amounts or subtractions is much simpler with algebraic representations.

We then had a look at some ratio problems. I commonly use one big bar to represent the whole amount, marking on the people with letters or similar, and then showing one share (top diagram). However, in the workshop we did this by drawing three separate bars, one underneath the other (bottom diagram).
Picture
I think both representations have their merits. Using one big bar links more easily into fraction/ratio equivalence and finding fractions of amounts. I've certainly had a lot of success in getting students to understand and do ratio problems using this. However, in problems where the difference between two people's shares is important, I can see how separate bars make it easier to compare or find differences.

The problem for this diagram was something along the lines of:
There are 300 students in two groups, A and B. A has 50 more students than B. How many in each group?
Picture
This was a great example of when a bar model would probably be one of the most efficient ways to solve this quickly.

The biggest thing I got out of this workshop was that the bar model is not just another method to get students to pass exams. For most exam questions, it's probably fairly inefficient, although I'd like to hope that with enough work on bar modelling, it might mean that students can try to tackle problems even if they are unsure of exactly what the question is asking. However, it really should be embedded in our maths curriculum as a powerful tool for developing understanding and as a stepping stone from concrete to abstract. 

One last thing mentioned was Math Playground; I've had a quick look and they have some great tools for creating and solving bar model problems. Here's one I made earlier:
Picture
Bar modelling | Math Playground


Comments are closed.

    Categories

    All
    #29daysofwriting
    A Level
    Algebra
    Algebra Tiles
    Area
    Assessment
    Bar Model
    Bar Modelling
    Books
    Celebration Of Maths 2015
    Challenge
    Circles
    CPD
    Cuisenaire Rods
    Data
    Decimals
    Displays
    Enrichment
    Equations
    Events
    Feedback
    Formulae
    Four Operations
    Fractions
    Functional Maths
    Gcse 2015
    GCSE Past Papers
    GCSE Revision
    Graphs
    Group Work
    HCF And LCM
    History Of Maths
    Intervention
    Investigation
    Lesson
    Lesson Ideas
    Literacy
    Lotw
    Loving Maths
    Manipulatives
    Marking
    Mastery
    #mathsconf
    #mathsconf2015
    #mathsconf4
    Maths In Pictures
    Multiplication
    Musings
    Negative Numbers
    News
    Numeracy Across Curriculum
    Parenthood
    Percentages
    Pick Of Twitter
    Pie Charts
    Primes
    Probability
    Problem Solving
    Proportion Problems
    Puzzles
    Pythagoras
    Quadratics
    Quadratic Sequences
    Ratio Tables
    Real Life Graphs
    Reflection
    Resources
    Revision
    Rounding
    Schemes Of Work
    Simultaneous Equations
    Square Numbers
    Stationery
    #summerblogchallenge
    #teacher5adaysketch
    Teaching And Learning
    Technology
    Top Ten
    Trignometry
    Trigonometry
    Vectors
    Venn Diagrams
    Websites
    Weebly Tutorials
    Zoombinis


    Archives

    August 2020
    September 2018
    August 2018
    October 2017
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    February 2016
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.